Thursday, October 15, 2009

AS-IS Clause in Horse Purchase Contract Article


I recently bought a horse and discovered it has a pre-existing lameness issue that the seller knew about and failed to disclose. I would like to return the horse, but the seller refuses based on the “AS-IS” clause of our contract. Is there any way to deal with an “AS-IS” contract?

Absolutely. When there is fraud in the inducement of the contract, the buyer can seek to rescind or unwind the contract.

The “AS-IS” clause is a favorite among horse sellers and is commonly found in sales contracts. In a horse sales contract, the “AS-IS” clause is used to describe a sale of a horse in its then-existing condition. The use of the phrase “AS-IS” or “With All Faults” will generally relieve the seller of any liability for visible and observable existing defects.

Where the seller has knowledge of a pre-existing condition and fails to disclose that information to the detriment of the buyer, the buyer can seek rescission of the contract based on fraud. The “AS-IS” language will not protect a seller from liability for the seller’s fraudulent representations.

If a seller misrepresents the condition of the horse or intentionally conceals any of the horse’s defects that are not otherwise visible or observable by the buyer and that misrepresentation or concealment affects the value or desirability of the horse, the seller cannot escape liability through an “AS-IS” clause.

Both intentional misrepresentation and the concealment of a material fact are forms of fraud. Seller’s failure to disclose a material fact such as a previous surgery to correct a lameness issue would constitute a concealment of a material fact. Seller actively injecting a horse to mask a lameness issue and failing to disclose that injection and lameness issue would constitute an intentional misrepresentation. Once a buyer determines fraud has taken place, the buyer should seek to repudiate the contract in a prompt and timely manner. Buyers should note that general statements by the seller regarding the horse’s soundness or ability to win blue ribbons in the future may not rise to the level of fraud and would most likely be considered “puffing” by the courts.

A pre-purchase exam can often determine whether the horse has any visible or observable defects that may affect the horse’s performance or value. Unfortunately, a typical pre-purchase exam does not include x-rays or blood work and many pre-existing conditions and medications can go undetected.

In an effort to avoid costly litigation, sellers with knowledge of a problem or condition that may render the horse less valuable or desirable than that which the buyer bargained for should always error on the side of disclosure. Buyers should also further protect themselves and include both x-rays and blood work in their pre-purchase exams.

If you would like more information on this or other topics, please feel free to visit our website at or contact our office at 949-264-1464.

This article is meant to provide general information only and is not intended to constitute legal advice. The information in this article is not intended to establish an attorney-client relationship between attorney and reader. The contents of this article are not a substitute for seeking the advice of legal counsel.

© Copyright 2009. Legal Equestrian, a Professional Law Corporation All rights reserved.

Thursday, July 16, 2009

A quick look at Legal Equestrian

Legal Equestrian, a PLC was formed in 2007 to meet the unique needs of the equine industry in California.

Because California does not have a specific set of legal statutes that address the needs of the equine community, the courts rely on a variety of statutes including but not limited to contract law, tort law and probate law. An attorney who is familiar with the needs of the horse community and is up to date on current equine law development is able to better analyze equine breeding, buying, selling and management issues in a timely manner.Parties often find themselves embroiled in litigation that is expensive, time-consuming and unpredictable simply because they entered into a transaction without a written agreement. The handshake deal does not work anymore.

Special Services Offered

Legal Equestrian offers customized contracts, purchase sale agreements, lease agreements, boarding contracts, hauling release and waivers, liability releases, training contracts, business formations, horse insurance advice, authorization to treat, full service litigation of all horse related disputes, breeding contracts, horse injury disputes, and mortality disputes.